Home | MyGov

Accessibility
Accessibility Tools
Color Adjustment
Text Size
Navigation Adjustment
Screen Reader iconScreen Reader

Desirability and Feasibility of Changing the Financial Year

Desirability and Feasibility of Changing the Financial Year
Start Date :
Aug 24, 2016
Last Date :
Oct 01, 2016
00:00 AM IST (GMT +5.30 Hrs)
Submission Closed

The Government of India has appointed a Committee chaired by Dr. Shankar Acharya, former chief economic adviser, to examine the desirability and feasibility of having a ‘new ...

The Government of India has appointed a Committee chaired by Dr. Shankar Acharya, former chief economic adviser, to examine the desirability and feasibility of having a ‘new financial year’. Other distinguished members of the Committee are Shri K M Chandrasekhar, former Cabinet Secretary, Shri PV Rajaraman, former Principal Finance Secretary, Tamil Nadu and Dr. Rajiv Kumar, Senior Fellow Centre for Policy Research.

Presently, the financial year followed by governments in India runs from 1st April to the following 31st March.

This issue was last examined by the L K Jha Committee in 1985, whose recommendation to move to a financial year of January 1- December 31 (for Central and State Governments) was then not accepted by the then Government.

There are many arguments for and against the change in financial year which revolve around issues of budget and cash management by government, seasonality of government revenues and expenditure, impact of Monsoon on budget forecasting, working season, timelines involved in the legislative cycle of passage of Budget by the Parliament, international comparability of fiscal statistics, aligning government’s financial year with year for tax assessment and corporate accounting purposes. Some arguments are less on the intrinsic merit or demerit of the change but rather on the timing of the change when the change coincides with other developments impacting businesses.

This Discussion Forum seeks to invite inputs from everyone interested in this issue.

We welcome your comments, suggestions, information and documents on the Committee’s Terms of Reference and issues related to it. Please provide these latest by 30th September, 2016.

Reset
Showing 816 Submission(s)
Nithin Rajavelu
Nithin Rajavelu 9 years 7 months ago
To continue and in summary, given (I confess, from my limited knowledge on the subject of economic/fiscal policy) the benefits don't seem to justify the impact on the current state of affairs, I feel retaining the current fiscal year format would be prudent.
Nithin Rajavelu
Nithin Rajavelu 9 years 7 months ago
I am not fully up to speed on the merits and converse arguments for moving the fiscal year and note that quite a few countries have their fiscal year linked to the calendar year, but that about an equally the same number have an Apr-Mar fiscal year. Also, the largest economic power, the USA, has their government fiscal year from Oct to Sep, different from the majority of the counties. So I am unable to appreciate the argument of becoming a 'truly globalised economy' for changing the fiscal year.
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI 9 years 7 months ago
Sir, with evolving globalised patterns in the stock / futures market & trading arms, it will be wise to streamline our planning in a such a way that implementation is meticulous. This can happen only if the intent of new plan structures are presented by December end or at the beginning of the calendar year. Hence, a January to December year will be more suitable in a globalised economy.
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI 9 years 7 months ago
Sir, the finance bill is generally prepared after due / extensive consultation with banking heads, business associations, heads of organisations, economists & industrialists. The varying factor is the social spend of the government & global economic trends. Global economic trends will need to be monitored on a regular basis and hence it is the budgeting on social infrastructure, tax collections & deficit target that need close scrutiny.
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI 9 years 7 months ago
Sir, ideally, it would be wise to combine the rail budget & general finance bill as a presentation of intent, by the prime minister. Detailed tax structure & plan allocation can be by the Finance minister. This too becomes easier after the roll out of the GST, as the state & central components are specified & there will be more accountability even from small traders & greater tax compliance. If required individual ministers can make added presentations.
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI
SUCHITRA RAGHAVACHARI 9 years 7 months ago
Sir, the presentation of the yearly finance bill as also the viability of five year plans are debatable. With financial planning changing constantly, as sort of continuum, micro managing is what is needed. Weather forecasting too has improved. Also, rail fare / freight increases and price of petroleum products are decided based on market needs. Agricultural exports & imports are based on forecasting & stock. Hence, what is required is a broad outline, like a state of the union address in the USA
Rakesh Shukla
Rakesh Shukla 9 years 7 months ago
सम्माननीय, प्रधानमंत्री श्री नरेन्द्र मोदीजी सादर प्रणाम भारत सरकार वित्त वर्ष जनवरी से प्रारम्भ करने की दिशा में सोच रही है. जनवरी से वित्त वर्ष के साथ शिक्षण सत्र का शुभारम्भ करना भी अच्छा होगा. इससे भारत का शिक्षा कैलेंडर सरकार के कैलेंडर के हिसाब से बन जाएगा. जलवायु परिवर्तन के कारण भारत में गर्मी का समय बढ़ रहा है. ऋतु चक्र में हो रहे परिवर्तन का असर विद्यार्थियों पर भी पड़ता है. यदि शिक्षण सत्र जनवरी से आरंभ होगा तो परीक्षा का समय सर्दी में यानी अक्टूबर, नवम्बर रहेगा. राकेश शुक्ला
Saransh Dahiya
Saransh Dahiya 9 years 7 months ago
Please make it from 1st january to 31st december. As it becomes very tough for middle class family to pay taxes in the frst quarter of the year, during tht March-April month we have major works related with money. Our childrens start their school's new session in these two months and for that we have to spend a much handy amount. There are a lot more problems in keeping financial year from 1st april so please make it from 1st january from next year.